73 Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students

Thanksgiving is a time for family, food, and being thankful. But it can also be a great time for some fun and engaging discussions! That's where Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students come in. These questions are a fantastic way to get students thinking, laughing, and interacting with each other in a lighthearted way, making the holiday season even more enjoyable.

What Are Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students?

Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students are exactly what they sound like: prompts that present two equally appealing (or sometimes equally challenging!) options related to Thanksgiving. Instead of a simple "yes" or "no" answer, students have to pick one of the two scenarios. This makes them super engaging because they force a choice, often leading to hilarious debates and interesting insights into what people value or find funny about the holiday. They're popular because they're easy to understand, can be tailored to different age groups, and offer a low-pressure way to spark conversations and build connections. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to foster critical thinking and communication skills while celebrating the spirit of Thanksgiving.

Here's why they work so well:

They encourage creative thinking.
They promote discussion and debate.
They help students understand different perspectives.
They create a fun and memorable classroom or family activity.

Teachers and parents often use Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students in a few different ways:

As icebreakers at the beginning of a class or meal.
As conversation starters during downtime.
As prompts for writing assignments or creative storytelling.
As a fun way to wrap up a Thanksgiving-themed lesson.

Food Fantasies: Thanksgiving Dinner Dilemmas

Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner with a robot chef who makes perfect turkey every time but can't tell jokes, or your quirky grandma who might burn the pie but tells the funniest stories?
Would you rather only be able to eat mashed potatoes for Thanksgiving dinner, or only be able to eat cranberry sauce?
Would you rather have an unlimited supply of pumpkin pie but no gravy, or unlimited gravy but no pumpkin pie?
Would you rather your entire Thanksgiving feast be healthy, no-sugar, whole-wheat dishes, or be a carb-lover's dream with endless fried foods and sugary desserts?
Would you rather have to eat every meal for a week leading up to Thanksgiving using only chopsticks, or have to eat every meal using only your hands?
Would you rather have your favorite side dish appear in huge, unmanageable portions on your plate for every meal, or have it be completely unavailable for a month after Thanksgiving?
Would you rather have to sing a song about each food item before you eat it, or have to do a little dance?
Would you rather have your stuffing be completely dry and crumbly, or your gravy be completely flavorless?
Would you rather have to make a turkey out of vegetables for Thanksgiving, or have to make a pumpkin pie out of actual turkey meat?
Would you rather your Thanksgiving rolls always be slightly burnt, or always be slightly undercooked?
Would you rather have to eat the entire Thanksgiving meal backwards (dessert first, appetizer last), or have to eat every bite with a teaspoon?
Would you rather have a Thanksgiving feast where all the food is a single color (e.g., all orange), or a feast where all the food is the same texture (e.g., all crunchy)?
Would you rather have to eat your Thanksgiving meal while standing on one foot, or while wearing a blindfold?
Would you rather have an endless supply of stuffing but it tastes like cardboard, or a small amount of the best stuffing ever?
Would you rather have to say "thank you" to each individual food item before eating it, or have to pat each food item on the head?
Would you rather have your turkey be slightly too salty, or slightly too sweet?
Would you rather have to eat your entire Thanksgiving meal with a giant fork, or with a tiny spoon?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dinner served cold, or have it be unbearably spicy?
Would you rather have to choose between a mountain of mashed potatoes or a river of gravy for your entire Thanksgiving meal?
Would you rather have your pumpkin pie be savory instead of sweet, or have your turkey be sweet instead of savory?

Family Follies: Relative Riddles

Would you rather spend Thanksgiving with your family arguing about politics, or with strangers who keep trying to give you unsolicited advice?
Would you rather have your family sing karaoke all night long, or have them play charades with incredibly difficult prompts?
Would you rather have your relatives re-tell the same embarrassing stories about you all night, or have them all try to give you cooking tips that you didn't ask for?
Would you rather have your family play board games where you always lose spectacularly, or have them play video games where you have no idea what's going on?
Would you rather have your aunt ask you about your future career plans incessantly, or have your uncle ask you about your dating life incessantly?
Would you rather have your cousins teach you all the latest TikTok dances that you can't possibly do, or have them challenge you to a rap battle?
Would you rather have your family start a spontaneous talent show where everyone has to participate, or have them all decide to redecorate the living room during dinner?
Would you rather have to listen to your uncle's conspiracy theories for an hour, or have to help your aunt sort through an endless pile of old photographs?
Would you rather have your parents insist on taking an embarrassing family photo every hour, or have them force you to wear matching Thanksgiving outfits?
Would you rather have your entire family communicate only through interpretive dance for the day, or only through exaggerated accents?
Would you rather have your younger siblings constantly ask "Are we there yet?" for the entire day, or have your older siblings constantly tease you about everything?
Would you rather have to help your dad set up a complicated, multi-part puzzle, or help your mom organize a massive collection of holiday decorations?
Would you rather have your relatives play a scavenger hunt throughout the house that never ends, or have them play a game of "Guess Who" but with all the relatives?
Would you rather have to pretend you love a gift you absolutely don't, or have to politely decline an invitation you really wanted to accept?
Would you rather have your family start a sing-along to songs you've never heard of, or have them all want to watch a black and white movie from the 1930s?
Would you rather have your grandma try to set you up with everyone at the dinner table, or have your grandpa tell the same joke fifty times?
Would you rather have your family members all give you identical, slightly disappointing gifts, or have them all give you wildly different but equally useless gifts?
Would you rather have to watch a documentary about a subject you find incredibly boring with your family, or play a very competitive game of Pictionary where everyone is overly serious?
Would you rather have your entire family start a spontaneous drum circle with kitchen utensils, or have them all decide to learn a new folk dance together?
Would you rather have to tell your family one funny, made-up story about your year, or have to tell them one hilariously embarrassing true story about your year?

Travel Troubles: Journey Jitters

Would you rather travel to Thanksgiving dinner by horse and carriage, or by a unicycle?
Would you rather have to walk to Thanksgiving dinner in the snow, or have to take a rickety boat across a choppy lake?
Would you rather be stuck on a plane with screaming babies for the entire flight to Thanksgiving, or be stuck on a train with a very loud polka band?
Would you rather have to navigate using only a paper map in a dense forest, or have to rely on a broken GPS that keeps sending you in circles?
Would you rather have your car break down in the middle of nowhere with no cell service, or have your car be followed by a flock of very persistent pigeons?
Would you rather have to take a bus that makes 50 stops, or a train that goes in the opposite direction for half the journey?
Would you rather have to travel in a car with no windows, or a car with no seats?
Would you rather have to carry all your Thanksgiving food in a backpack for a 10-mile hike, or have it transported by a team of very slow-moving snails?
Would you rather have to travel to Thanksgiving dinner by a hot air balloon that keeps getting stuck in trees, or by a hot dog-shaped submarine?
Would you rather have your travel companion be someone who talks non-stop about their vacation stories, or someone who only communicates through sighs?
Would you rather have to ride a giant inflatable flamingo across a river to get to Thanksgiving, or ride a roller coaster that only goes backwards?
Would you rather have your GPS announce directions in a pirate voice, or a very slow robot voice?
Would you rather have to travel with a suitcase that’s perpetually on the verge of exploding, or a suitcase that constantly plays annoying circus music?
Would you rather have to take a detour through a corn maze, or a detour through a field of very ticklish geese?
Would you rather have your car's horn be replaced with a kazoo, or your car's engine be replaced with a bicycle pedal?
Would you rather have to travel by a small, wobbly rowboat for the entire trip, or by a giant, inflatable bouncy castle?
Would you rather have your destination be visible but unreachable for hours, or have your destination keep moving further away?
Would you rather have to wear a helmet made of actual pie crust during your travels, or have to sing sea shanties every time you hit a bump?
Would you rather have your travel companion be a talking squirrel who gives terrible directions, or a very polite but unhelpful robot?
Would you rather have to travel to Thanksgiving dinner through a tunnel of singing mannequins, or a field of giggling scarecrows?

Activity Adventures: Fun and Frustrating Pastimes

Would you rather spend Thanksgiving afternoon playing football in the mud, or trying to assemble a giant jigsaw puzzle with missing pieces?
Would you rather have to play a board game where the rules change every five minutes, or a card game where you can only hold three cards at a time?
Would you rather have to participate in a turkey-trot race where everyone wears giant turkey costumes, or a pie-eating contest where the pies are secretly made of vegetables?
Would you rather have to build a fort out of Thanksgiving leftovers, or create a Thanksgiving-themed sculpture out of aluminum foil?
Would you rather have to lead a group sing-along of Thanksgiving songs you don't know, or choreograph a spontaneous dance to an unknown song?
Would you rather have to tell everyone a joke that makes absolutely no sense, or try to explain a complicated concept using only hand gestures?
Would you rather have to wear a pilgrim hat and cape for the entire day, or a turkey costume with a squeaky beak?
Would you rather have to write a poem about your favorite Thanksgiving food that rhymes perfectly, or a story about a mischievous cranberry that has a surprising twist?
Would you rather have to spend the day trying to teach a group of very stubborn squirrels to do a Thanksgiving dance, or teach a flock of very confused pigeons to sing carols?
Would you rather have to create a Thanksgiving-themed obstacle course in your backyard, or a Thanksgiving-themed escape room in your living room?
Would you rather have to play a game of tag where the person who is "it" can only move by hopping, or a game of hide-and-seek where everyone has to sing when they are found?
Would you rather have to give a heartfelt speech about why you're thankful, but have to deliver it entirely in a silly accent, or have to sing a thank-you song in opera style?
Would you rather have to participate in a pumpkin rolling contest down a steep hill, or a corn-shucking competition where the corn is super prickly?
Would you rather have to build a gingerbread house that looks exactly like your own house, or a gingerbread house that looks like a famous landmark?
Would you rather have to tell everyone at the table a secret about yourself that you’ve never told anyone before, or guess one embarrassing secret about each person at the table?
Would you rather have to play a game of musical chairs where the music is played on a kazoo, or a game of Simon Says where Simon always gives impossible commands?
Would you rather have to create a Thanksgiving float for a parade using only recycled materials, or design a Thanksgiving-themed video game?
Would you rather have to make balloon animals in the shape of Thanksgiving foods, or juggle three small pumpkins?
Would you rather have to answer questions about Thanksgiving history with riddles, or answer questions about your own life with song lyrics?
Would you rather have to invent a new Thanksgiving tradition on the spot, or re-enact an old Thanksgiving tradition in a completely ridiculous way?

Supernatural or Silly: Fantastical Feast Choices

Would you rather have your Thanksgiving turkey come to life and grant you three wishes, or have your Thanksgiving pie be able to talk and give you life advice?
Would you rather have a ghost join your Thanksgiving dinner and tell spooky stories, or have a friendly alien join and share tales of outer space?
Would you rather have your table magically transform into a giant, floating boat for the meal, or have the room fill with edible clouds?
Would you rather have a magical cornucopia that always refills with your favorite snacks, but only when you're not looking, or a magic napkin that cleans up any mess instantly, but makes a silly sound?
Would you rather have to eat your Thanksgiving meal with utensils made of pure gold, or have to eat it with utensils made of candy?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving feast be served by invisible elves, or have your desserts levitate onto the table?
Would you rather have a talking turkey as your pet for the week after Thanksgiving, or a talking pumpkin that whispers secrets?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dinner be telepathically broadcast to everyone in the world, or have it be accompanied by a live orchestra playing Thanksgiving-themed music?
Would you rather have your wishes granted by a mischievous leprechaun who always twists your words, or by a wise old owl who speaks only in riddles?
Would you rather have a Thanksgiving dinner where all the food floats, or where all the food changes flavor with every bite?
Would you rather have to communicate with your family using only animal sounds for the day, or have to wear a hat that makes you invisible when you speak?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving leftovers animate and have a party in the kitchen, or have your Thanksgiving decorations come to life and dance?
Would you rather have to eat a meal where everything is the opposite of what it looks like (e.g., a salad that tastes like chocolate), or a meal where you can only eat with your feet?
Would you rather have a magical gravy boat that can refill itself infinitely, but also talks back, or a magical stuffing bowl that can produce any kind of stuffing, but only one spoonful at a time?
Would you rather have to share your Thanksgiving meal with a friendly dragon, or a family of talking squirrels?
Would you rather have your dreams the night before Thanksgiving be about flying on a turkey, or swimming in a sea of mashed potatoes?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving dessert be a giant, edible rainbow, or a cake that tells you compliments when you take a bite?
Would you rather have to wear a crown made of real Thanksgiving food for the day, or have to wear shoes that squish like mashed potatoes?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving table have a portal to a land of endless desserts, or a portal to a land of magical creatures who want to share their food?
Would you rather have to invite a historical figure to your Thanksgiving dinner, or a fictional character from your favorite book?

A Year of Thanks: Gratitude Goals

Would you rather be thankful for something amazing every single day for a year, but have to write it down in a diary, or be thankful for something small and silly every day, with no need to record it?
Would you rather have to thank someone publicly every week for the entire year, or privately thank ten people every month for the entire year?
Would you rather have to volunteer your time to help others every weekend for a year, or donate a portion of your allowance to charity every week for a year?
Would you rather be able to instantly master a new skill that benefits others every month, or be able to instantly solve one problem for someone else every week?
Would you rather have to express your gratitude through elaborate song and dance performances, or through incredibly heartfelt and detailed letters?
Would you rather have the power to make one person in the world feel truly happy every day, or the power to make one small, positive change in the environment every day?
Would you rather have to always offer help to anyone who asks, even if it’s inconvenient, or have to be the person who identifies and solves problems before anyone else notices them?
Would you rather be able to give the perfect gift to anyone, anytime, but never receive gifts yourself, or receive incredible gifts but be unable to give any?
Would you rather have to share your biggest accomplishments with a supportive group of friends every week, or keep them private and reflect on them alone?
Would you rather be able to inspire kindness in others with a single word, or be able to spread laughter with a single gesture?
Would you rather have to dedicate an hour each day to learning about different cultures and perspectives, or an hour each day to mastering a craft that brings joy to others?
Would you rather be able to erase one act of unkindness from history, or be able to create one act of profound generosity in the present?
Would you rather have to express your gratitude through acts of service, or through expressions of genuine admiration?
Would you rather have the ability to make everyone around you feel understood, or the ability to make everyone around you feel excited?
Would you rather have to write a thank-you note for every good thing that happens to you, no matter how small, or perform a random act of kindness for someone else every time you feel thankful?
Would you rather be able to share your deepest gratitude through art, or through music?
Would you rather have the power to remind people of their strengths, or the power to help them overcome their weaknesses?
Would you rather have to create a "gratitude jar" for your community and encourage participation, or personally deliver thank-you messages to local heroes?
Would you rather be able to feel everyone's happiness, or be able to share your own happiness with everyone?
Would you rather have to celebrate small victories with extravagant parties, or have to reflect on big achievements with quiet contemplation?

So, there you have it! A whole bunch of Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions For Students to get everyone talking and laughing. Whether you're using these for a classroom activity, a family gathering, or just to spark some fun conversations, they're a wonderful way to embrace the holiday spirit and get those brains buzzing. Happy Thanksgiving!