73 Horrible Would You Rather Questions
73 Horrible Would You Rather Questions

Ever played a game where you have to choose between two really tough or just plain weird options? That's pretty much what "Horrible Would You Rather Questions" are all about! They're the kind of questions that make you pause, cringe a little, and maybe even giggle at the sheer absurdity of it all. These aren't your everyday "would you rather have pizza or tacos" questions; they dive into the stuff that makes you think, "Ugh, I really don't want to pick either of those!"

What Makes a Horrible Would You Rather Question?

Horrible Would You Rather Questions are designed to present you with two equally unappealing, bizarre, or morally challenging choices. They're not about picking the fun option; they're about confronting uncomfortable possibilities and exploring the limits of what you'd tolerate. Think of it as a mental obstacle course, where every path leads to a slightly uncomfortable or downright dreadful outcome. The goal is to force a difficult decision, making you really consider your preferences and perhaps even uncover some hidden anxieties or surprising strengths.

These kinds of questions are super popular because they're a fantastic way to break the ice, get people talking, and inject some fun into social gatherings. They can be used in a variety of settings, from casual hangouts with friends to more structured team-building activities. Here's why they work so well:

  • They spark conversation.
  • They reveal personality traits.
  • They create memorable moments.
  • They're a great way to relieve stress through laughter.

The importance of these questions lies in their ability to create shared experiences and foster connections through laughter and sometimes, even a bit of shared discomfort. They can be a surprisingly effective tool for understanding how others think and react to challenging scenarios.

Physical Horrors

  1. Would you rather have fingers for toes or toes for fingers?
  2. Would you rather constantly feel like you have a small pebble in your shoe or a single hair in your eyeball?
  3. Would you rather have to sneeze every time you try to speak or hiccup every time you try to laugh?
  4. Would you rather sweat cheese or cry mayonnaise?
  5. Would you rather have itchy all over for the rest of your life or sticky all over for the rest of your life?
  6. Would you rather have your ears constantly whistle show tunes or your nose honk like a clown car?
  7. Would you rather have to walk everywhere on your hands or crawl everywhere on your belly?
  8. Would you rather have your teeth fall out one by one every day until you have none, and then they grow back, or have your fingernails and toenails grow continuously and have to cut them every hour?
  9. Would you rather have to eat a bowl of live spiders or drink a gallon of your own sweat?
  10. Would you rather have your skin slowly turn a bright neon color that you can't change or have your hair grow at an inch a day?
  11. Would you rather always smell like rotten eggs or always have a mouth full of chalk?
  12. Would you rather have your dominant hand permanently covered in a mild, persistent rash or have your dominant foot always feel like it's asleep?
  13. Would you rather have to eat everything with chopsticks that are as long as your arm or eat everything with tiny spoons the size of your pinky nail?
  14. Would you rather have an uncontrollable urge to bark at strangers or an uncontrollable urge to meow at loved ones?
  15. Would you rather have your dreams be constantly invaded by your worst fears or have your waking moments be plagued by a song you hate stuck on repeat?
  16. Would you rather have to wear a full suit of medieval armor every day or have to wear a giant inflatable T-Rex costume every day?
  17. Would you rather have your voice sound like a chipmunk or have your voice sound like a grumpy old man?
  18. Would you rather have to relive the most embarrassing moment of your life once a week or have to confess your most embarrassing secret to a stranger every day?
  19. Would you rather have to lick every doorknob you touch or have to kiss every lamppost you pass?
  20. Would you rather have to sing everything you say or have to whisper everything you say?

Gross Food Dilemmas

  1. Would you rather eat a live slug or a jar of earwax?
  2. Would you rather drink a milkshake made of blended cockroaches or a smoothie made of blended eyeballs?
  3. Would you rather eat a sandwich filled with toenail clippings or a salad topped with maggot larvae?
  4. Would you rather have to eat a whole raw onion like an apple every morning or drink a glass of pickle juice mixed with hot sauce every night?
  5. Would you rather have your favorite meal permanently replaced with lukewarm gruel or have your favorite drink permanently replaced with dishwater?
  6. Would you rather eat a plate of ants or a bowl of earthworms?
  7. Would you rather have to eat a raw potato like a carrot every day or eat a raw egg like a shot every day?
  8. Would you rather eat a pizza with pineapple and anchovies or a burger with jellybeans and pickles?
  9. Would you rather have to eat a bar of soap every week or drink a cup of spoiled milk every day?
  10. Would you rather have to eat everything you're served, no matter how disgusting, or only be able to eat food that is the exact same color?
  11. Would you rather eat a whole lemon, peel and all, or drink a cup of vinegar?
  12. Would you rather have to eat a spoonful of mayonnaise mixed with mustard or a spoonful of ketchup mixed with soy sauce?
  13. Would you rather eat a rotten banana or a spoiled orange?
  14. Would you rather have to eat a bug every time you feel hungry or eat a tiny pebble every time you feel thirsty?
  15. Would you rather eat a whole garlic clove like candy or eat a whole chili pepper like a grape?
  16. Would you rather have your food always be slightly burnt or always be slightly undercooked?
  17. Would you rather eat a bowl of raw pasta or a bowl of uncooked rice?
  18. Would you rather have to eat a spoonful of expired baby food or a spoonful of cat food?
  19. Would you rather eat a sandwich filled with soggy bread and canned beans or a pizza with a crust made of crackers?
  20. Would you rather drink the water from a stagnant pond or eat a meal prepared with sewer water?

Awkward Social Situations

  1. Would you rather accidentally send a highly embarrassing text message to your boss or accidentally post a highly embarrassing photo on your family's social media?
  2. Would you rather have to break up with your current partner in front of their entire family or have to confess your biggest secret to a room full of strangers?
  3. Would you rather have to sing an apology song to someone you've offended or have to write a 10-page essay explaining why you were wrong?
  4. Would you rather have to wear a sign that says "I'm a terrible dancer" everywhere you go or have to admit to everyone you meet that you don't know how to tie your shoelaces?
  5. Would you rather accidentally call your teacher "Mom" or "Dad" every day for a month or accidentally call your boss by your pet's name every day for a month?
  6. Would you rather have to tell your crush that you've been secretly stalking them or have to admit to your best friend that you've been secretly gossiping about them?
  7. Would you rather accidentally walk into the wrong bathroom and see someone naked or accidentally interrupt a marriage proposal?
  8. Would you rather have to give a public speech about your least favorite subject or have to perform a talent you don't have in front of a large crowd?
  9. Would you rather have to attend a party where you know absolutely no one and have to make small talk for hours or have to attend a party with your most annoying relatives and have to pretend to enjoy their company?
  10. Would you rather have to reveal your most embarrassing internet search history or have to reveal your most embarrassing diary entry?
  11. Would you rather have to ask for directions every five minutes, even if you know where you're going, or have to narrate your every action out loud?
  12. Would you rather have to pretend to be a character from a TV show for a whole day or have to speak in a made-up language that no one understands for a whole day?
  13. Would you rather have to wear a giant novelty hat to every important meeting or have to carry a rubber chicken with you everywhere you go?
  14. Would you rather have to explain your entire life story to a complete stranger on public transport or have to defend your questionable life choices to a panel of judges?
  15. Would you rather have to apologize to a baby for crying or apologize to a dog for barking?
  16. Would you rather have to wear a bright pink tutu and ballet slippers to work or wear a full knight's costume to a casual dinner party?
  17. Would you rather have to sing "Happy Birthday" to everyone you meet on their birthday, even if you don't know them, or have to give everyone a personalized, slightly awkward compliment every day?
  18. Would you rather accidentally leave your microphone on during a very private conversation or accidentally send a screenshot of your private chat to a group chat?
  19. Would you rather have to confess a made-up embarrassing secret to your boss or confess a real, but minor, embarrassing secret to your entire family?
  20. Would you rather have to attend a formal event in your pajamas or have to give a presentation in a room full of people who are all wearing clown noses?

Unusual Pains

  1. Would you rather have your fingernails grow into your palms or your toenails grow into your soles?
  2. Would you rather have a constant buzzing sound in your ears or a constant feeling of static electricity all over your body?
  3. Would you rather have your bones ache like you have arthritis or your muscles twitch uncontrollably?
  4. Would you rather feel like you're constantly being tickled by a feather or have tiny needles poking your skin every few seconds?
  5. Would you rather have a persistent dull headache or a sharp, stabbing pain that comes and goes randomly?
  6. Would you rather have your eyes water uncontrollably or your nose run uncontrollably?
  7. Would you rather feel like you're always on the verge of sneezing or always on the verge of a yawn that you can't complete?
  8. Would you rather have your tongue feel like it's coated in sandpaper or your lips feel like they're perpetually chapped?
  9. Would you rather have a constant feeling of pins and needles in your limbs or a constant feeling of your muscles being cramped?
  10. Would you rather have your skin feel like it's crawling with insects or have your hair feel like it's perpetually greasy and unwashed?
  11. Would you rather have your breath always smell like garlic or have your sweat always smell like onions?
  12. Would you rather have to stub your toe every morning or accidentally hit your funny bone every evening?
  13. Would you rather have a phantom itch that you can never quite scratch or a phantom ache that you can never quite pinpoint?
  14. Would you rather have your ears feel like they're stuffed with cotton balls or have your nose feel like it's constantly clogged?
  15. Would you rather have your teeth feel like they're vibrating or your jaw feel like it's constantly clenched?
  16. Would you rather have a constant low-grade fever or a constant feeling of being extremely cold?
  17. Would you rather have your vision blur in and out or have your hearing fluctuate in intensity?
  18. Would you rather have your skin feel like it's constantly sunburned or have your hair feel like it's constantly static-charged?
  19. Would you rather have a persistent metallic taste in your mouth or a persistent sour taste in your mouth?
  20. Would you rather have your legs feel like jelly or your arms feel like lead weights?

Existential Nightmares

  1. Would you rather live in a world where everyone else can read your thoughts but you can't read anyone else's, or live in a world where everyone else can hear your thoughts but you can't hear anyone else's?
  2. Would you rather know the exact date and time of your death, but be unable to change it, or never know when you'll die, but always have the possibility of a sudden, unexpected end?
  3. Would you rather have the ability to control your dreams but have nightmares every time you sleep, or have normal dreams but be unable to control them at all?
  4. Would you rather relive the same day over and over for eternity, but be able to change your actions each time, or have your life play out exactly as it's meant to, with no control over anything?
  5. Would you rather be the last person on Earth, with all the resources you could ever want, or be one of billions, struggling for survival in a dying world?
  6. Would you rather have the power to undo one past mistake, but suffer immense personal consequences for it, or live with your mistakes forever, but experience no further negative repercussions?
  7. Would you rather have a perfect memory of everything you've ever experienced, but also remember every pain and suffering, or have a selective memory that forgets all negative experiences, but also forgets all positive ones?
  8. Would you rather be immortal but forget everyone you've ever loved, or live a normal lifespan and remember every single person you've ever known?
  9. Would you rather have the ability to see the future, but be powerless to change it, or have the ability to change the past, but face unpredictable and potentially worse consequences?
  10. Would you rather have your entire life documented and publicly broadcast for everyone to see, or have your life erased from all records and memories once you die?
  11. Would you rather be trapped in a simulation that feels completely real but is ultimately fake, or live in a harsh, brutal reality that is undeniably true?
  12. Would you rather have the power to grant yourself any physical ability, but lose all your emotional capacity, or have the power to feel every emotion intensely, but have no physical capabilities?
  13. Would you rather be constantly watched by an omniscient being, but be safe and protected, or be completely free but constantly in danger?
  14. Would you rather have the ability to communicate with animals, but they all hate you, or be unable to communicate with animals, but they all love you?
  15. Would you rather have your consciousness transferred into a robot body, losing your humanity but gaining immortality, or remain human and face inevitable decay?
  16. Would you rather have the ability to forget any painful memory at will, but also forget how to feel love, or be unable to forget any memory, but also feel love more intensely?
  17. Would you rather live in a world where everyone is completely honest, even when it's hurtful, or live in a world where everyone lies constantly, even about good things?
  18. Would you rather have your greatest fear manifest physically and have to confront it daily, or have your greatest desire fulfilled, but know it was achieved through a terrible sacrifice by someone else?
  19. Would you rather have the ability to pause time, but you age rapidly while time is paused, or have the ability to fast-forward through boring parts of your life, but miss important moments?
  20. Would you rather be forgotten by everyone you've ever met, but have lived a fulfilling life, or be remembered by everyone, but have lived a life of constant regret?

Absurd Scenarios

  1. Would you rather have to fight a hundred duck-sized horses or one horse-sized duck?
  2. Would you rather have your nose constantly drip snot or your ears constantly produce earwax?
  3. Would you rather have to wear shoes made of raw steak or a hat made of live bees?
  4. Would you rather have to communicate only through interpretive dance or only through opera singing?
  5. Would you rather have to live in a house made entirely of cheese or a house made entirely of LEGOs?
  6. Would you rather have to fight a giant sentient broccoli or a swarm of tiny, angry squirrels?
  7. Would you rather have your sweat smell like cheap perfume or your tears smell like old socks?
  8. Would you rather have to travel everywhere by unicycle or by pogo stick?
  9. Would you rather have to wear a cape made of sandpaper or a mask made of sandpaper?
  10. Would you rather have to befriend a colony of intelligent, talking cockroaches or a single, giant, extremely polite spider?
  11. Would you rather have to eat everything with oven mitts on or wear oven mitts as gloves all the time?
  12. Would you rather have your shadow try to escape from you every time you're alone or have your reflection in mirrors judge your every move?
  13. Would you rather have to wear a hat that screams every time you're nervous or shoes that honk with every step?
  14. Would you rather have your favorite food taste like dirt or have your least favorite food taste like your favorite food?
  15. Would you rather have to paint your entire house with your own blood or have to build a second story on your house using only your teeth?
  16. Would you rather have to talk to inanimate objects as if they were alive or have inanimate objects talk to you as if you were an inanimate object?
  17. Would you rather have to carry a rubber chicken with you everywhere you go, and have to present it to people you meet, or have to wear a sign that says "I'm a talking banana" everywhere you go?
  18. Would you rather have to fight a yeti using only a pool noodle or a kraken using only a rubber duck?
  19. Would you rather have to eat a pizza with anchovies and marshmallows or a hamburger with jellybeans and peanut butter?
  20. Would you rather have your farts sound like a trumpet solo or your sneezes sound like a foghorn?

So, there you have it – a collection of "Horrible Would You Rather Questions" to get your brain buzzing and your friends debating. These questions, while sometimes a little unsettling, are a fantastic way to explore different perspectives and have a good laugh at the absurdities of life. They might push your boundaries a bit, but that's part of the fun! So go ahead, throw some of these out there and see what interesting, hilarious, or surprisingly thoughtful answers you get.

Related Articles: