73 Christian Would You Rather Questions

Welcome to the fun world of Christian Would You Rather Questions! These are special kinds of questions designed to make you think, laugh, and maybe even have a little debate with your friends. They're a fantastic way to explore your faith and see how you might respond to different scenarios, all while having a good time. Let's dive in and see what kinds of interesting choices we can make!

What Are Christian Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They Great?

So, what exactly are Christian Would You Rather Questions? Simply put, they're questions that give you two choices, and you have to pick the one you'd rather do. But here's the twist: both choices are usually related to Christian values, biblical stories, or situations that a person of faith might face. They're not just about silly things; they often touch on important beliefs and how we live them out. Think of them as mini-dilemmas that help you ponder what matters most in your walk with God.

These questions are super popular for a bunch of reasons. First, they're a great icebreaker and a fun way to connect with others who share your faith. You can play them in youth groups, with family, or even just with a friend. Second, they encourage discussion. When you ask someone "Would you rather A or B?", they have to explain why they chose what they did. This can lead to some really insightful conversations about scripture, personal convictions, and how we understand God's word. The importance of these discussions lies in building understanding, strengthening community, and deepening individual faith. They help us learn from each other and see different perspectives on how to live a Christ-like life.

Here are some ways people use Christian Would You Rather Questions:

As a fun activity during Bible study or youth group meetings.
To spark conversations about faith and values.
To help people think through their beliefs and how they apply them.
As a way to learn more about biblical stories and characters in an engaging way.
Just for a good laugh and some lighthearted fun!

Bible Character Dilemmas

Would you rather be Noah and build an ark in a desert with no rain, or be Moses and part a very shallow puddle?
Would you rather be David fighting Goliath with a slingshot that only shoots marshmallows, or be Samson with his hair accidentally shaved by a toddler?
Would you rather be Jonah trying to preach to Nineveh with a terrible sore throat, or be Elijah arguing with 450 prophets of Baal while having a terrible case of hiccups?
Would you rather be Abraham trying to sacrifice Isaac on a mountain that’s also a very popular ski resort, or be Lot’s wife and have to constantly look back at a city that's now a giant salt lick?
Would you rather be Peter trying to walk on water during a hurricane, or be Paul trying to explain theology to a group of squirrels?
Would you rather be Ruth gleaning in a field that's just a giant sandbox, or be Esther trying to impress a king who only communicates through interpretive dance?
Would you rather be Joseph interpreting dreams for Pharaoh, but Pharaoh only dreams about pizza toppings, or be Daniel in the lion's den, but the lions are all vegetarian and just want to cuddle?
Would you rather be Mary Magdalene presenting Jesus with a bouquet of plastic flowers, or be the Samaritan woman at the well trying to get her 10th husband to notice her with a broken water jug?
Would you rather be John the Baptist preaching in the wilderness while being chased by a swarm of very friendly but insistent butterflies, or be Jesus feeding the 5,000 with only a single cracker and a bottle of water?
Would you rather be Adam naming all the animals in a zoo where all the signs are smudged, or be Eve trying to convince a serpent to eat an apple that's actually a rubber toy?
Would you rather be Paul shipwrecked on an island where the only inhabitants are parrots who speak King James English, or be Silas and Timothy singing hymns in a prison cell that is also a bouncy castle?
Would you rather be a disciple trying to explain the loaves and fishes miracle with only two tiny fish and five breadsticks, or be Martha stressing about the party decorations while Lazarus is still asleep in his tomb?
Would you rather be Solomon judging a dispute between two people over a single, slightly bruised grape, or be a prophet delivering a message to a king who is more interested in his video game?
Would you rather be Stephen being stoned but all the stones are actually soft pillows, or be a disciple trying to cast out a demon that's just really good at doing the robot dance?
Would you rather be Joshua leading the Israelites around Jericho, but the trumpets are actually kazoos, or be Gideon with his 300 men fighting an army of very polite garden gnomes?
Would you rather be Rehab hanging her scarlet rope from a window that’s actually a trapdoor, or be Simon Peter denying Jesus but the rooster is actually a very loud alarm clock?
Would you rather be Balaam’s donkey complaining about the angel with a very high-pitched squeaky voice, or be Aaron making the golden calf out of melted down credit cards?
Would you rather be Job losing all his possessions but gaining a lifetime supply of really good cookies, or be Joseph sold into slavery but landing a gig as the royal chef?
Would you rather be Mary (mother of Jesus) trying to sing a lullaby to Jesus while a herd of very noisy sheep are in the stable, or be Joseph trying to build a manger out of spaghetti?
Would you rather be Judas returning the 30 pieces of silver to a bank teller who insists it’s insufficient funds, or be Caiaphas trying to explain Jesus' teachings to a committee of really confused pharisees?

Everyday Faith Challenges

Would you rather have to pray out loud in a crowded elevator every time it stops, or have to sing your Bible verses instead of saying them?
Would you rather always have to wear clothes that are slightly too small or slightly too big, or have to speak with a lisp whenever you talk about your faith?
Would you rather be known for your amazing generosity but accidentally give away your own shoes, or be known for your deep prayer life but fall asleep during every sermon?
Would you rather have to apologize to every inanimate object you bump into, or have to say "Praise God!" after every single bite of food you eat?
Would you rather have the Holy Spirit speak to you only through very cheesy 80s pop songs, or have to give a compliment to a stranger every time you see them?
Would you rather have to forgive someone who stole your favorite snack every single day for a week, or have to perform a random act of kindness for someone who is incredibly grumpy?
Would you rather your prayers always be answered with a delayed "maybe" instead of a yes or no, or have to share your most embarrassing moment with your entire church congregation?
Would you rather have to wear a sign that says "Blessed and Highly Favored" all day, every day, or have to publicly thank God for every meal in a dramatic opera voice?
Would you rather only be able to listen to Christian music for the rest of your life but it’s all Gregorian chants, or only be able to read the Bible but it’s written in crayon?
Would you rather have to offer unsolicited spiritual advice to everyone you meet, or have to share your deepest fears and insecurities with a complete stranger?
Would you rather have to give a sermon every Sunday on a topic you know absolutely nothing about, or have to lead worship using only a kazoo and a tambourine?
Would you rather have to tell everyone you meet that you saw an angel, even if you didn't, or have to constantly apologize for being too holy?
Would you rather have your phone automatically send Bible verses to your boss when you’re late, or have your car horn replaced with a loud gospel choir singing "Hallelujah"?
Would you rather have to live in a house where every single surface is covered in sticky notes with Bible verses, or have to constantly speak in riddles that have biblical answers?
Would you rather have to give away half of your possessions every month to a charity you don't agree with, or have to serve a particularly annoying person with extreme kindness and patience?
Would you rather have to speak to your pet in Bible verses all the time, or have to explain Christian concepts to a group of very skeptical aliens?
Would you rather have your most private thoughts broadcast to your small group, or have to perform dramatic reenactments of Bible stories at work?
Would you rather have to fast from all social media for a year for a good cause, or have to give up all your favorite snacks for a month to help someone in need?
Would you rather have to dedicate all your free time to volunteering for a cause you find boring, or have to share your home with a very messy but incredibly faithful person?
Would you rather your shadow always point towards the nearest church, or have to sing hymns every time you walk down the street?

Biblical Commandments & Ethics

Would you rather have to always tell the absolute truth, even if it hurts someone deeply, or have to lie to protect someone's feelings, even if it's a big lie?
Would you rather always have to honor your parents' wishes, even if they seem unreasonable, or have to stand up for your own beliefs, even if it causes family conflict?
Would you rather never covet anything anyone else has, but constantly feel like you're missing out, or be able to desire things but always feel guilty about it?
Would you rather always have to avoid even the appearance of evil, meaning you can never do anything remotely questionable, or have to actively fight against evil, even if it puts you in danger?
Would you rather have to forgive someone who has deeply wronged you 70 times 7, meaning an endless cycle of forgiveness, or have to take revenge for a wrong done to you, even a small one?
Would you rather always have to remember and observe the Sabbath day, meaning no work or errands ever, or have to constantly work and serve others, even at the expense of your own rest?
Would you rather have to honor your elders and leaders by always obeying them, even if you disagree, or have to question and challenge authority when you believe they are wrong?
Would you rather never take the Lord's name in vain, but have to use religious phrases in everyday conversation, or be able to speak casually about God, but risk using His name disrespectfully?
Would you rather always have to avoid gossip and slander, but you can never defend yourself when others speak badly of you, or be able to speak out against injustice, even if it means engaging in potentially divisive speech?
Would you rather always have to be truthful in your dealings, even if it means losing a business deal, or be able to bend the truth slightly to achieve a greater good, like providing for your family?
Would you rather have to always show mercy and compassion, even to those who don't deserve it, or have to uphold justice and righteousness, even if it means being harsh?
Would you rather have to give generously to the poor and needy, even if you have very little yourself, or have to manage your resources wisely and save for the future, even if it means less giving?
Would you rather always have to speak words that build others up, but you can never express criticism, or be able to offer constructive criticism, even if it might sound negative?
Would you rather have to always be humble and never boast about your accomplishments, even if they are significant, or be able to share your successes to inspire others, even if it risks sounding proud?
Would you rather always have to be patient and wait for God's timing, even if it means long delays and frustration, or take action and try to speed things up, even if it's not God's will?
Would you rather have to love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, even if they are truly awful, or defend yourself and your loved ones aggressively when threatened?
Would you rather always have to be content with what you have, even if you are struggling, or be motivated to improve your situation and seek more, even if it leads to dissatisfaction?
Would you rather have to always forgive others quickly and completely, even for unforgivable offenses, or have the right to hold grudges and seek justice when wronged?
Would you rather always have to be a peacemaker, even if it means compromising your own convictions, or stand firm on your principles, even if it leads to conflict?
Would you rather have to live a life of radical obedience, doing exactly what the Bible says without question, or have a life of thoughtful application, discerning how to best live out God's will in complex situations?

Heavenly & Spiritual Scenarios

Would you rather have a direct hotline to God that works 24/7 but you can only ask yes or no questions, or have the ability to understand every language ever spoken, but you can only speak in rhymes?
Would you rather be able to fly but only when you're singing worship songs, or have the ability to teleport but only to places where you've recently eaten a sandwich?
Would you rather have an angel as your personal bodyguard who is incredibly powerful but also a terrible comedian, or have a demon you have to constantly outsmart, but he’s surprisingly good at making toast?
Would you rather receive a divine download of all biblical knowledge but forget how to tie your shoes, or be able to perform one daily miracle but it always involves making really bad puns?
Would you rather have your prayers answered instantly but they are always answered with a riddle, or have your prayers take a week but they are always answered with a perfectly baked cookie?
Would you rather be able to see into the spiritual realm but all the angels look like pigeons, or be able to hear the whispers of the Holy Spirit but they sound like your grandma nagging you?
Would you rather have a personal halo that glows brightly but it attracts all the mosquitoes in a five-mile radius, or have a personal choir of angels that sing your praises but they only sing off-key?
Would you rather be able to perform acts of great faith that always go slightly wrong in a funny way, or be able to have perfect wisdom but you can only share it through interpretive dance?
Would you rather be able to communicate with animals but they only speak in Bible verses, or be able to heal the sick but you have to sing them a lullaby first?
Would you rather have a direct pathway to heaven that’s a slide made of pure light but it’s very fast and bumpy, or have a chariot that takes you to heaven but it’s pulled by very slow-moving snails?
Would you rather be able to hear God’s voice clearly but it sounds like a kazoo, or be able to see Jesus’ face but he’s wearing a silly hat?
Would you rather have the gift of prophecy but you can only predict when it’s going to rain, or have the gift of tongues but you can only speak in ancient Sumerian?
Would you rather have a personal cloud that follows you around and rains blessings, but the blessings are always slightly inconvenient, or have a guardian angel who is fiercely protective but constantly trying to set you up on dates?
Would you rather be able to perform acts of selfless service that always result in mild embarrassment, or have perfect patience but you can only express it through interpretive eyebrow wiggling?
Would you rather have your sins instantly forgiven but you have to wear a scarlet letter for a week, or have to work off your sins through an eternity of folding laundry?
Would you rather be able to understand the thoughts of all believers but they are all focused on what to have for lunch, or be able to see the blessings of God but they are all disguised as everyday chores?
Would you rather have a direct line to the Holy Spirit that allows you to ask for anything, but you have to sing your request like an opera singer, or have the ability to instantly repent for any sin but you have to confess it to a stranger?
Would you rather be able to preach with incredible power but your voice randomly turns into a squeak, or be able to lead worship with amazing musical talent but you can only play the spoons?
Would you rather have a personal rainbow that appears whenever you're happy, but it’s always a bit crooked, or have a dove that delivers your messages, but it always gets lost on the way?
Would you rather be able to discern good from evil but you can only do it by smelling things, or be able to feel the presence of the Holy Spirit but it feels like a mild static shock?

Christian Life & Choices

Would you rather spend a year volunteering in a soup kitchen where the food is always bland but the people are wonderful, or spend a year teaching Sunday school to the most unruly kids imaginable but they learn incredibly quickly?
Would you rather always have to pray for your enemies with genuine love and compassion, even if they are truly awful people, or have to physically defend yourself and your loved ones at all costs when threatened?
Would you rather give away half of your possessions to a charity you deeply believe in, or give away half of your possessions to a charity you have strong reservations about?
Would you rather live a life of quiet devotion with no public recognition but with immense inner peace, or live a life of influential ministry that impacts many but comes with constant scrutiny and pressure?
Would you rather have to forgive someone who has wronged you grievously every single time they ask, no matter how many times, or have the right to set boundaries and hold someone accountable for their actions?
Would you rather dedicate your life to spreading the Gospel in a dangerous and unreached part of the world, or dedicate your life to serving the poor and marginalized in your own community?
Would you rather have to constantly speak words of encouragement and affirmation to everyone you meet, even if you don't mean it, or have to speak the truth in love, even if it means delivering difficult messages?
Would you rather always have to be content with your current circumstances, even if they are challenging, or be driven by a desire for improvement and growth, even if it leads to dissatisfaction?
Would you rather have your prayers answered immediately with a "yes" or "no," but you have no idea why, or have your prayers take time but you always understand the wisdom behind the answer?
Would you rather be a great theologian who can explain complex doctrines but struggles to show compassion, or be deeply compassionate but have a limited understanding of theological nuances?
Would you rather have to share your faith boldly and publicly, even if it makes you feel awkward and judged, or share your faith quietly and privately through your actions and example?
Would you rather always have to follow the letter of the law, even if it seems unmerciful, or always have to focus on the spirit of the law, even if it means bending the rules?
Would you rather have the gift of healing but it only works on plants, or have the gift of prophecy but you can only predict minor inconveniences like traffic jams?
Would you rather spend your life building a large, well-known Christian organization, or spend your life serving faithfully in a small, humble ministry that no one notices?
Would you rather have to always act with perfect integrity, even when no one is watching, or be able to compromise slightly for the sake of getting things done more efficiently?
Would you rather be able to discern people's spiritual gifts but you can never tell them what they are, or be able to encourage people in their faith but you can never point out their weaknesses?
Would you rather have to spend an entire day confessing every minor sin you've ever committed to a pastor, or have to publicly perform a dramatic reenactment of a biblical parable?
Would you rather always have to be a peacemaker, even if it means sacrificing your own desires, or always have to stand firm on your convictions, even if it leads to conflict?
Would you rather have the ability to instantly become fluent in any foreign language but only Christian hymns, or be able to remember every Bible verse but forget your own name?
Would you rather live a life of radical obedience, doing exactly what the Bible says without question, or have a life of thoughtful application, discerning how to best live out God's will in complex situations?

Joyful & Silly Faith Fun

Would you rather have your halo be a brightly colored disco ball, or have your wings made of oversized, fluffy feathers that shed everywhere?
Would you rather sing every song in church with a booming opera voice, or dance your way down the aisle every time you enter?
Would you rather have a personal cloud that follows you around and sprinkles glitter, or have a friendly unicorn that delivers your mail?
Would you rather have your shoes automatically tie themselves with Bible verses, or have your clothes always be made of the softest, most comfortable gospel-themed fabric?
Would you rather have a personal choir of angels who sing you to sleep every night, but they only sing lullabies about sheep, or have a pet lion who is incredibly loyal but occasionally tries to lick you to death?
Would you rather your prayers always be answered with a funny voice message from God, or have your Bible automatically glow and play a jingle when you open it?
Would you rather have the ability to float a few inches off the ground when you're really happy, or be able to communicate with plants, and they always tell you Bible jokes?
Would you rather have your name changed to a biblical character of your choice, but you have to respond to it with a dramatic bow every time, or have to wear a tiny crown every time you're feeling particularly blessed?
Would you rather have your tears turn into small, edible cookies of blessing, or have your laughter create a shower of confetti that always spells out a Bible verse?
Would you rather have a personal rainbow that appears whenever you sneeze, or have a choir of little cherubs who follow you around and offer helpful (but often silly) advice?
Would you rather have your shadow always point towards the nearest bakery that makes heavenly pastries, or have your footsteps always leave behind a trail of glitter?
Would you rather have a guardian angel who is incredibly skilled at juggling, or have a pet dragon who breathes out blessings instead of fire?
Would you rather have your car horn replaced with the sound of a heavenly choir singing "Hallelujah" every time you honk, or have your doorbell play a worship song that changes every day?
Would you rather have your shadow always wear a funny hat that changes every day, or have your reflection in the mirror wink at you when you're feeling extra faithful?
Would you rather have a personal dove that delivers your prayers to heaven, but it always stops for snacks along the way, or have a rainbow bridge that appears whenever you need to cross a puddle?
Would you rather have your laughter sound like wind chimes made of pure joy, or have your sighs sound like gentle waves crashing on a peaceful shore?
Would you rather have your eyebrows spontaneously sprout little halos when you're deep in prayer, or have your hair turn into a halo of light when you're feeling particularly righteous?
Would you rather have a pet sheep that follows you everywhere and bleats out Bible verses, or have a pet giraffe with a very long neck that can reach heavenly scriptures?
Would you rather have your smile radiate a soft, golden glow when you're feeling blessed, or have your walking stick magically produce a stream of holy water when you tap it?
Would you rather have a personal cheerleader angel who encourages you with pom-poms made of scripture, or have a pet angel fish that swims around your head and sings blessings?

So there you have it! Christian Would You Rather Questions are a wonderfully versatile tool for fun, learning, and connection. Whether you're using them to spark deep conversations about faith, to lighten the mood with some playful scenarios, or to simply get to know your friends better, these questions offer a unique way to explore what it means to live a life guided by Christian principles. Keep asking, keep answering, and most importantly, keep growing in your faith!